Water and Spirit

Francis Martin and William M. Wright IV. The Gospel of John. Grand Rapids, MI: BakerAcademic, 2015.

Sometimes when you’ve read a book enough times it’s hard to notice anything new in it; or even anything at all. That’s what’s so nice about Martin and Wright’s new commentary on The Gospel of JohnBy reading John’s gospel slowly they manage to bring a old book to life. In addition to a straightforward commentary that restates the gospel account in other words, Martin and Wright include side-bars explaining how concepts such as “The Word” or “The Son of Man” are used elsewhere in the Bible, discussions of what John means when he says “The Jews,” and excerpts by great Christian writers from Origen to Theresa of Avila to Pope Francis who have commented on these same passages in other contexts. Sometimes the contributions of this “Living Tradition” – as Martin and Wright Augustine of Hippocall it – get right to the heart of the matter. When discussing whether people are solved by God’s irresistible call or by their own choice, for example, Augustine argues: “Do not think that you are drawn unwillingly; the mind is also drawn by love. … [It] may be said to us, “How do I believe by will, if I am drawn?” I say, it is not enough by will; you are also drawn by pleasure.” Including these sorts of gems within the sort of popular and accessible commentary that Martin and Wright offer adds a whole new dimension to the format of a traditional commentary.

Jesus calls PeterThe first thing that struck me when reading this book is that The Gospel of John is not just a biography of Jesus but that it preaches, well, the gospel. Time and time again the evangelist challenges us to accept the good news that Jesus brings. After the opening hymn tells us that the Word become flesh has “dwelt” (Gk. skenoo) among us just as God “dwelt” (LXX skene) with His people in the Tabernacle and in Solomon’s temple, John the Baptist appears, testifying to Jesus’ identity as the Messiah (Jn 1:29-34). Then Jesus arrives, calling first his disciples (Jn 1:35-51), then Nicodemus, the good Jew (Jn 3:1-21), the Samaritan woman at the well (Jn 4:1-42), and finally the gentile official (Jn 4:43-54) as His offer of salvation spreads ever further afield. Although Jesus ministers to Jews throughout His public ministry, it is only when “some Greeks” come seeking Him out that He declares that His “hour has come” (Jn 12:23) and sets out for the cross.

Thinking about the calling of the disciples, Martin and Wright note: “Intimately connected with this revelation of Jesus is the call to discipleship.  … Jesus calls each one of us to intimacy with him. His call summons us out of our comfort zones to obey him. At first, the call may be simply to begin a prayer life, to break off a pattern of sin, or to be reconciled with someone. Since it is a divine call, it has a mysterious attraction and bears a promise, which at first may be only dimly heard. If we take a step in the direction of Jesus – if we begin to pray, start to act on something we know he wants – then we, like the first disciples, will come to know him better and to “remain” with him.”

He Qui Samaritan Woman at the WellJesus visits Jerusalem for religious festivals four times in John’s gospel, and Martin and Wright do an excellent job of explaining how Old Testament echoes shape this gospel.  Jesus’ words to Nicodemus about being “born of water and spirit” (Jn 3:5) remind us of God’s promise to Ezekiel that He will cleanse his people with “clean water” and put His “spirit within” them (Ez 36). Greeting Jesus with palm branches when he enters Jerusalem (Jn 12:13) echoes the way Jews greeted victorious warriors during the Maccabean rebellion (1 Macc 13:51). When Jesus meets the Samaritan woman at the well, Martin and Wright comment that “the location at the well recalls biblical stories featuring Isaac, Jacob, and Moses where encounters at wells lead to marriage. Moreover, the biblical account of Samaritan religious history includes the imported gods, which lingered in Jewish memory. In this light, when Jesus speaks of the woman’s husbands, he is concerned not only with her relationship history but, even more, with the Samaritans’ relationship with God: the woman’s five husbands symbolize the pagan gods of five nations mentioned in 2 Kings 17. Jesus thirsts not only for water but, more important, for a permanent union between the Samaritans and the Father.”

Trinity iconJohn’s gospel is also full of Christological and Trinitarian statements.  Jesus tells the Samaritan woman who is awaiting the Messiah that “I am he, the one who is speaking with you” (Jn 4:26). Martin and Wright comment that “The expression “I am he” renders a Greek phrase (ego eimi) that is literally “I am.” Jesus is not only acknowledging his messiahship, he is also identifying himself with the divine name.” Jesus uses the same phrase when He walks on the water towards the disciples and tells them “It is I” (Jn 6:20). Martin and Wright note that “whereas in the Synoptics the disciples are frightened because they think they see a “ghost” (Matt 14:26, Mark 6:49), in John there is no such suggestion. The disciples know exactly who and what they see, and this sight provokes fear.” Jesus’ next words, “Do not be afraid,” are totally appropriate because this is what God always says whenever He appears to humans. People respond similarly to Jesus when the armed crowd looks for him in the garden of Gethsemane: “When He said to them ‘I AM,’ they turned away and fell to the ground.” (Jn 18:6). Discussions about Jesus’ divinity continue when He is arguing about His identity with the Pharisees and needs two witnesses to back up His statements (as required by Jewish law). Jesus says, “I testify on my behalf and so does the Father who sent me” (Jn 8:18), telling us that He and His Father are two distinct persons. But then in the very next verse He states that “If you knew me, you would know my Father also” (Jn 8:19), which is a striking claim about the unity of the Father and the Son. Written at a much later date than the synoptics, John’s gospel was already starting to wrestle with some of the Trinitarian formulations that would obsess the Church for the next couple of hundred years, and Jesus makes these sorts of claims about Himself again (10:31) and again and again.

Peter denies JesusWhereas the first half of the gospel is characterized by the spread of light wherever Jesus goes, darkness dominates the second half. Judas goes out into the night, a crowd arrests Jesus carrying torches, because they are living in spiritual darkness. While Jesus is being interrogated by Annas, the father-in-law of the high priest, Peter goes into the courtyard. Martin and Wright comment that by joining the group by the fire, “Peter put himself in a difficult situation” by mingling with the enemies of His master, and this leads him directly into denying Christ. We find ourselves in these sorts of situations far too often, and although we, like His captors, share “the gravest responsibility for the torments inflicted upon Jesus,” we too can experience the same mercy that Peter did. The gospel ends with Jesus, who is the Shepherd of God’s people par excellence, inviting Peter to become a shepherd too. Martin and Wright conclude: “No matter how serious or how many sins we have committed (Peter’s were very serious), the love and mercy of Jesus is infinitely greater. He seeks us out and invites us to return to him. This scene should give us confidence that when we seek reconciliation with Jesus, he forgives us completely and forever.” And that is good news indeed!


I would like to thank NetGalley for providing me with a review copy of this eBook.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s